Jag tror många som bara har läst traditionell västerländsk filosofi kommer märka att det Buddhistiska tillvägagångsättet för att lösa kunskapens problem skiljer sig rätt rejält från hur det västerländska ter sig.
Som sagt, dessa saker här i texten bygger inte på lösryckta hypotetiska spekulationer, utan detta är återberättande av praktiska erfarenheter.
Brotherhood of Knowledge
As inquiry and investigation unfold the dynamics of observation, interpretation, and negation, three different kinds of knowledge are revealed. We can think of them as being like three brothers.
The youngest brother understands what is known as consisting of what has appeared historically. Reality is ‘what has happened’, and his responsibility is to find out what this is.
The second brother sees the value of what the youngest is doing, but does not agree that the proper domain of knowledge is ‘what has been presented’. Basic structures such as the three times or existence in space all need to be investigated. And so he invites his brother to go further and do more. He knows that investigation exercises knowledge and awakens intelligence, fostering a more healthy and complete way of being.
The third, oldest brother is pleased with what has already been done, but suspects that both his brothers may be lazy, or else that they fail to see their situation as a whole. In his view, the second brother still wants to reach a final destination—a goal or resting place where he can stop and say, “This is it!” To counteract this tendency, he is alert to point out to his brother that ‘this’ is not ‘it; that there is no ‘it’ and no holding onto something as established and beyond questioning. He is always asking his brother why he wants to stop—but is careful not to set up another form of ‘wanting’ instead. He is confident that knowledge can be self-validating.
Although all three brothers remain the best of friends, their understanding differs greatly. For the first brother, history—the domain of objective fact—is the witness to knowledge. The structure within which knowledge takes place is not an appropriate subject for inquiry, except perhaps in a historical or ‘objective’ way. He finds his brothers’ activity incomprehensible, perhaps even subversive.
For the second brother, inquiry and the intelligence that it fosters are the witnesses to knowledge. He sees the structures on which his younger brother relies as ‘read-outs’ that restrict knowledge, and explores those ‘read-outs’ so that the artificial restraints they impose can be dissolved. He recognizes inquiry itself as knowledge in action, and delights in the opportunity to deepen and extend his intelligence. He worries that his oldest brother has taken on an exhausting, hopeless task. For there will always be more ‘read-outs’, stretching backward and forward in time and extending throughout space, even shaping space and time themselves.
The third brother, too, sees the ‘read-outs’ that the second brother has discovered, but understands them in a more fundamental way as instances of what could be called the ‘read-out principle’. He sees that there are only self-validating ‘read-outs’; nothing else. And he recognizes that even this ‘nothing-else’ is a ‘read-out’. He explains to his younger brother that his anxiety is groundless: There is no one to be exhausted and no task to be accomplished. There is only the ‘read-out principle’ itself, which is not ‘self-validating’ but ‘self-negating’. The only witness to knowledge is knowledge.
Grateful for the vital work performed by his two younger brothers, the third brother devotes himself to sharing with them the fruits of his realization, without insisting on these fruits as ‘real’ in the way that his brothers might think. He invites them to participate in a global knowledge.
But even this possibility requires a certain level of understanding. According to the first-level understanding of the first brother, global knowledge is impossible, for it would require traveling to the ends of the universe to discover the whole of the existent realm. No one has the power to do this: Time is too short, and ‘locatedness’ in space imposes insurmountable limits.
For the second brother, global knowledge is likewise impossible. We can discover new layers’ of space and new ‘rhythms’ within time; we can penetrate the realms of the known to disclose the unknown. But the whole of what appears in space and time – the infinite range of possible ‘read-outs’ – is too vast to be encompassed by such a knowing.
For the third brother, however, knowledge is global from the outset. It ‘contains’ the universe and constitutes all ‘read-outs’. Through the intimacy of knowledge with time and space, an intimacy of knower and known manifests as fundamental. The objects of knowledge do not ‘approach’ us, nor must we journey ‘somewhere else’ to know ‘more’. For it is the nature of time, space, and knowledge to be inseparable. As we come to embody space and time, knowledge is revealed as intrinsic to the nature of all being." (Tarthang Tulku, Love of Knowledge, pp. 365-368)
"We can, then, distinguish three levels of relating to ‘knowingness.’ On the first, we draw heavily upon the ‘knowingness’ of Great Knowledge, but are unaware of doing so. The overall character of such a condition has been described at length in Chapters Eleven through Thirteen.
By cultivating more clarity and knowingness, we can attain the second level, which permits us to form a new vision of the status and interrelationship of the elements constituting ordinary reality. We can see what it might mean for such elements to be a totality in some way. We see that such totality can be approached and attained as a lived view rather than just an abstract conception. As we approach the totality and embrace even more of it, we come to have a different understanding of what ‘totality’ means. It turns out not to be a thing or aggregate of component things. It is not a matter of quantity. The closer our approach, the more we see that the approach must itself reflect the nature of totality, which includes the fact that it is not a result of an additive process.
An approach to totality requires that we re-evaluate our relation to ordinary things, that we cease to rob them of their value and significance by accepting them as finite, discrete isolates. For no attempt to assemble a comprehensive view out of such a restrictive relation to ‘individuals’ will succeed. We can reach everything, but not by reaching out in the old ways predicated on ‘not having’. The ‘everything’ which is finally realized is not the ‘whole universe’ postulated by our initial view or read-out.
A second level acquaintance with ‘knowingness’ shows everything—the entire universe—to be more open-ended in scope by showing a great deal more space, time, and encounters to be available, pervading and surrounding all apparently finite things and intervals. In this way, finite things are appreciated in a way that is more in keeping with their Space, Time, and Knowledge nature. However, the result, the ‘output’ of this appreciation, is still expressed in terms of the first level view of things, meanings, quantities, and so on. There is still a reality, but it is no longer of determinate extent.
In the more developed phases of the second level, presentations are offered which do not fit into even a quantitatively extended picture of that world order. Rather, they suggest a collapse of that order or the peeping through of others. These are all still due to interpreting Space-Time- Knowledge in accordance with ordinary parameters.
On the third level of understanding, where Great Knowledge is completely exposed, there is no fixed universe or totality because there is only Space and Time. Things are Space and Time, but in the sense that there are no things at all—-any appearance is purely Space and Time. There are neither units nor a total. Often this would be interpreted as a comment about ‘reality’—-that, for instance, reality is open-ended, without fixed boundaries, without being made up of particular sets or types of ‘things’, and without being in a particular state at a given time. But for the Space-Time-Knowledge vision, totality—-the comprehensive view and way of being—-does not involve any ‘reality’ that could, for instance, be open.
Space, Time, and Knowledge are ‘what is’ without this meaning that they are things that are, such as a fundamental substratum, truth, or reality. Their openness is not in any sense a condition. Similarly, totality is not supportive of things or of something beyond things. This point is important for understanding the path of this vision, because without it, the second-level accommodation of Space-Time-Knowledge to ordinary views could lead to a dead-end experience of a ‘Whole’. Since initial motives for making progress would have been put to rest in such an absorption, we could become stuck—-until Time began to free us again, offering us the chance of opening and knowing more.
When totality is understood in a truly liberating (rather than freezing) way, we have attained the third level. But what specifically is liberated by this attainment? Is it the body, the mind, the personality, emotions,external environment, blades of grass, rocks, wind—-what? If in asking this we want to preserve a concern for first level presuppositions, so that the question relates to the things of the ordinary world view, the answer is “Everything!” Our awakening is the awakening of all those, apparently in the past or yet to come, who have attained it. It is also the awakening of everyone who is apparently still fettered by ordinary views.
From the perspective of first level read-outs, it seems that we are making effort and progress as individuals, so that the third stage goal should be an individual attainment. However, rather than being drawn further and further away from the rest of the world through our transcending efforts, we become more appreciative of what everything is and more intimately integrated with it. This is not really a merging or awakening of ordinary ‘things’, but a switchover to a view which sees all things as being no things—no things which need to be transformed
or unified. Every ‘thing’ is perfectly integrated as Space-Time-Knowledge." ~ Tarthang Tulku, Time, Space, and Knowledge, pp. 283-286)
