Källa: http://www.integralworld.net/augustine13.html
Detta är en fallstudie av samma författare som denna artikel: http://www.filosofiforum.com/forum/vie ... php?t=7048
.........
One particular moral issue I believe deserves a great deal of attention and discussion is the notion of healthcare, namely within the United States. In this paper, I will argue that we can better understand the reason underlying our current healthcare debate by recognizing its connection to the gender distinctions, in relation to morality, as outlined by Carol Gilligan's care ethics. I will claim that the reason why someone most likely supports privatized healthcare is that this individual is most strongly influenced by a masculine ethical viewpoint, while the reason why someone most likely supports publicized healthcare is conversely that this individual is most strongly influenced instead by a feminine ethical viewpoint. Because masculine morality emphasizes justice over care, rules over relationships, and autonomy over communion, this means that it is more likely to support privatized healthcare. Because feminine morality contrastingly emphasizes care over justice, relationships over rules, and communion over autonomy, this means that it is more likely instead to support publicized healthcare. In this essay, I will stress the significance of autonomy, in particular, as illustrating masculine morality in addition to the significance of communion, in particular, as illustrating feminine morality. Let us begin this discussion first by briefly reviewing Gilligan's philosophy.
Gilligan calls into question the nature of and basis for a majority of ethical theories prevalent within Western philosophy. She contests the way most if not all prominent ethicists throughout history have approached the subject of morality is one-sided and partially exclusive. Just as we can perceive a Gestaltian image in one of two ways, and just as both of these ways are equally legitimate modes of seeing the phenomenon, so we can apply the same principle to how we regard morality. Throughout history, (male) philosophers have considered morality and its prescription to be a matter of theoretical justification in order to produce a solid principle of some sort on which to base all ethical decisions:
The justice perspective, often equated with moral reasoning, is recast as one way of seeing moral problems and a care perspective is brought forward as an alternate vision or frame.
Gilligan tells us that this moral view – the justice perspective – is but one end of the whole spectrum, which the care perspective complements.
.....
fortsättningen finns i källlänken ovan