Finite and Infinite Games

Moderator: Moderatorgruppen

Användarvisningsbild
nytt namn
Inlägg: 782
Blev medlem: 23 okt 2009 06:42

Finite and Infinite Games

Inläggav nytt namn » 08 jan 2011 22:14

Jag hittade häromdagen en riktigt intressant bok, "Finite and Infinite Games"
Alla källor är från: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finite_and_Infinite_Games

Finite vs. Infinite

With this philosophy text, Carse demonstrates a way of looking at actions in life as being a part of at least two types of what he describes as "games", finite and infinite. Both games are played within rules, as agreed upon by the participants; however, the meaning of the rules are different between the two types of games. The book stresses a non-serious (or "playful") view of life on the part of "players", referring to their choices as "moves", and societal constructs and mores as "rules" and "boundaries".

His idea is that when a person sees themselves as "playing" in "games" usually seen as serious events, they are more likely to keep an open mind and find themselves less bothered by things that might have troubled them a lot in the past (although that can be an overgeneralized statement, as Carse frequently stresses that sometimes seriousness is a required rule of play in a finite game).

He regularly uses familiar terms in similar, but more metaphorical meanings – such as his use of the terms boundaries vs. horizons in that boundaries are "rules" that one must stay within when playing a finite game, while horizons move with the player, and are constantly changing as he or she "plays". The use of "deeper" meanings to everyday words is a common tool in philosophy and academia.

In short, a finite game is played with the purpose of winning (thus ending the game), while an infinite game is played with the purpose of continuing the play.

Finite games have a definite beginning and ending. They are played with the goal of winning. A finite game is resolved within the context of its rules, with a winner of the contest being declared and receiving a victory. The rules exist to ensure the game is finite. Examples are debates, sports, receiving a degree from an educational institution, belonging to a society, or engaging in war. Beginning to participate in a finite game requires conscious thought, and is voluntary; continued participation in a round of the game is involuntary. Even exiting the game early must be provided for by the rules. This may be likened to a zero sum game (though not all finite games are literally zero sum, in that the sum of positive outcomes can vary).

Infinite games, on the other hand, do not have a knowable beginning or ending. They are played with the goal of continuing play and a purpose of bringing more players into the game. An infinite game continues play, for sake of play. If the game is approaching resolution because of the rules of play, the rules must be changed to allow continued play. The rules exist to ensure the game is infinite. The only known example is life. Beginning to participate in an infinite game may be involuntary, in that it doesn't require conscious thought. Continuing participation in the current round of game-play is voluntary. "It is an invariable principle of all play, finite and infinite, that whoever plays, plays freely" (p. 4).


...
The wisdom held in this brief book now informs most of what I do in life. Its key distinction--that there are two types of games, finite and infinite--resolves my uncertainties about what to do next. Easy: always choose infinite games. The message is appealing because it is deeply cybernetic, yet it's also genuinely mystical. I get an "aha" every time I return to it.
-- KK
...
Sample Excerpts:

A finite game is played for the purpose of winning, an infinite game for the purpose of continuing the play.

Finite players play within boundaries; infinite players play with boundaries.

To be prepared against surprise is to be trained. To be prepared for surprise is to be educated.

The death of an infinite player is dramatic. It does not mean that the game comes to an end with death; on the contrary, infinite players offer their death as a way of continuing the play. For that reason they do not play for their own life; they live for their own play.

I can be powerful only by not playing, by showing that the game is over.

Infinite players do not oppose the actions of others, but initiate actions of their own in such a way that others will play by initiating their own.

Evil is the termination of infinite play.

No one can play a game alone.

There is but one infinite game.
...
Notes on Finite and Infinite Games
by James P. Carse
1. There are at least two kinds of games. One could be called finite, the other infinite.
A finite game is played for the purpose of winning, an infinite game for the purpose of
continuing the play.
2. There is no game, finite or infinite, unless the players freely agree to play it. No one can
play who is forced to play. This is an invariable principle of all play. Whoever must play,
cannot play.
If a finite game is to be won by someone, it must come to a definitive end. It will come to
an end when someone has won. Winning is determined by agreement of the players.
3. A finite game has a precise beginning and end, and has clear spatial and numerical
boundaries. There must be at least one opponent.
5. In a finite game there can be only one winner, but other players may be ranked at the end
of play.
6. Other than the principle of voluntarism, infinite games are the opposite of finite games in
every way. Infinite games have no spatial, temporal, or numerical boundaries, and no
winners or rankings. Finite games are externally defined; infinite games are internally
defined. The time of an infinite game is determined in the game itself.
7. Finite games can be played within an infinite game, but no infinite game can be played
within a finite game.
10. The rules of a finite game are predetermined and fixed. The rules of an infinite game
must change in the course of play, to avoid a finite outcome. The rules of an infinite
game are changed to prevent anyone from winning and to bring as many persons as
possible into the play.
14. To be playful is not to act as if nothing of consequence will happen. When we are playful
with each other we relate as free persons; everything that happens is of consequence. In
fact, it is being serious that closes itself to consequence, for seriousness is the dread of the
unpredictable outcome of open possibility. To be serious is to press for a specified
conclusion; to be playful is to allow for possibility whatever the cost to oneself.
17. Surprise in infinite play is the triumph of the future over the past. Since infinite players
do not regard the past as determining the present/future, they have no way of knowing
what has begun in the past. With each surprise, the past reveals a new beginning.
Inasmuch as the present/future is always surprising, the past is always changing.

To be prepared against surprise is to be trained. To be prepared for surprise is to be
educated. Education discovers an increasing richness in the past, because it sees what is
unfinished there. Training regards the past as finished and the future as to be finished.
Education leads to a continuing self-discovery; training leads toward a final selfdefinition.
Training repeats a completed past in the future. Education continues an
unfinished past into the future.
Källa: http://www.glg.net/pdf/Finite_Infinite_Games.pdf

Användarvisningsbild
nytt namn
Inlägg: 782
Blev medlem: 23 okt 2009 06:42

Inläggav nytt namn » 08 jan 2011 22:29

Jag tycker boken var intressant, främst för att den försöker svara på liknande frågeställningar som jag försökt klargöra.
Författaren av boken är professor i teologi och även religionshistoria. Han tycks dela mitt intresse för "spel/lek" och "religon/authencitet".

Han använder ordet "geni" i meningen jag använder "auktoritär".

(Auktoritet = author = upphovsman = ursprung/skapare) jmf med: (“Genius” is used here in its original sense of “creator” or “generator.”)

...

Se även mina två trådar:
http://www.filosofiforum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=4023
http://www.filosofiforum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=4639

Användarvisningsbild
nytt namn
Inlägg: 782
Blev medlem: 23 okt 2009 06:42

Inläggav nytt namn » 08 jan 2011 22:30

En annan sak:
"Authencitet kontra Legitimitet" är två begrepp Wilber använder, och dessa motsvarar bra mot begreppen "Infinite game" (dvs. Authencitet) och "Finite game" (dvs. Legitimitet).

...

Modernism är att "formalisera" tillvaron i ett "finit spel", varpå Postmodernismen påvisar det "finita" i det "finita spelet" - problemet här, vilket gör att modernismen får ett "legimitietsproblem".

Problemet med postmodernism, är att de reducerar allt till "ett spel" (maskerat som "en mångfald av lokala finita spel"). Problemet med detta, är att man då blandar ihop legitimitet och authencietet - varpå tanken om "universiella mänskliga rättigheter" är något som måste förkastas (e.g. tanken om mänskliga rättigheter, i sitt anspråk på det "infinita spelet" blir ett "finit spel", och är alltså enligt postmodernism, "ett spel").

Kulturrelativismen dekonstruerar således "kulturen" när barriären mellan authencitet och legitimitet slås ihop.


Återgå till "Filosofi"

Vilka är online

Användare som besöker denna kategori: 66 och 0 gäster