Jag har bara snabbt skummat igenom artikeln och blir lite fundersam.
Är fysiken falsifierbar?
Hur bör begreppet falsifiering användas och hur långt sträcker dess giltighet/rimlighet?
Någon som funderat på detta?
För att citera ett stycke om Popper:
Wikipedia skrev:Popper is perhaps best known for repudiating the classical observationalist-inductivist account of scientific method by advancing empirical falsifiability as the criterion for distinguishing scientific theory from non-science; and for his vigorous defense of liberal democracy and the principles of social criticism which he took to make the flourishing of the "open society" possible.
Wikipedia skriver allmänt om falsifiering:
Detta exempel gäller ju som sagt ett rationellt antagande utifrån empirism, dvs ett logiskt fastställande utifrån en sinnesobservationer av svanar.Popper held that science could not be grounded on such an invalid inference. He proposed falsification as a solution to the problem of induction. Popper noticed that although a singular existential statement such as 'there is a white swan' cannot be used to affirm a universal statement, it can be used to show that one is false: the singular existential observation of a black swan serves to show that the universal statement 'all swans are white' is false - in logic this is called modus tollens. 'There is a black swan' implies 'there is a non-white swan' which in turn implies 'there is something which is a swan and which is not white', hence 'all swans are white' is false, because that is the same as 'there is nothing which is a swan and which is not white'.
Exempel de tar upp och diskuterar på Wikipedia artikeln om Falsifiering är: Logic and mathematics, Ethics, Theism, Conspiracy theories, Economics, Historicism, Memetics, Solipsism, Physics. Men det som slår mig är att alla dessa, för mig tycks, vara rationellt grundade. Ingen av dessa exempel bygger på empirism, det är så jag upplever det iaf, eftersom vi kan inte observera dessa saker med våra sinnen.
Sen funderade jag på detta det var specifikt om Historicism:
Popper verkar här dra väldigt hårt likamedtecken mellan empirism och vetenskap (och utesluter alltså rationalism som bas för vetenskap). Eller?Theories of history or politics which allegedly predict the future course of history have a logical form that renders them neither falsifiable nor verifiable. They claim that for every historically significant event, there exists an historical or economic law that determines the way in which events proceeded. Failure to identify the law does not mean that it does not exist, yet an event that satisfies the law does not prove the general case. Evaluation of such claims is at best difficult. On this basis, Popper himself argued that neither Marxism nor psychoanalysis were science, although both made such claims. Again, this does not mean that any of these types of theories are necessarily incorrect. Popper considered falsifiability a test of whether theories are scientific, not of whether propositions they contain or support are true.
Så är begreppet falsifiering bara relevant när någon gör ett logiskt/rationellt antagande om ett empririskt "fakta"? Någon som har idéer? Är det något jag missförstått angående falsifikation, rationalism, empirism?
(Notera även att det finns olika betydelser hos begrepper empirism/empiri, dels en vetenskaplig och en dels filosofisk innebörd http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empiricism )
