Pilatus skrev:rekoj skrev:Kant exempelvis? Skrev tjocka böcker med många okända begrepp. Huruvida han bidrog med klarhet eller kaos beror väl på vem som frågas.
Det är inte alltid så enkelt, för vem kan intuitivt förstå Kants tanke att syntetiska omdömen a priori kan vara berättigade?
Utmaningen tänker jag mer kan vara att förstå
hur de är berättigade.
Som Nietzsche uttryckte det
Nietzsche skrev:Above everything else, Kant was first and foremost proud of his table of categories. With this table in hand, he said, "That is the most difficult thing that ever could be undertaken on behalf of metaphysics."- But people should understand this "could be"! He was proud of the fact that he had discovered a new faculty in human beings, the ability to make synthetic judgments a priori. Suppose that he deceived himself here. But the development and quick blood of German philosophy depend on this pride and on the competition among all his followers to discover, if possible, something even prouder - at all events "new faculties"! But let's think this over. It's time we did. "How are synthetic judgments a priori possible?" Kant asked himself. And what did his answer essentially amount to? Thanks to a faculty [Vermöge eines Vermögens]. However, unfortunately he did not answer in three words, but so labouriously, venerably, and with such an expenditure of German profundity and flourishes that people failed to hear the comical niaiserie allemande [German stupidity] inherent in such an answer. People even got really excited about this new faculty, and the rejoicing reached its height when Kant discovered yet another additional faculty - a moral faculty - in human beings, for then the Germans were still moral and not yet at all "political realists." Then came the honeymoon of German philosophy. All the young theologians of the Tubingen seminary went off right away into the bushes - all looking for "faculties."
Problemet handlar med andra ord inte om att Kant skrev om syntetiska a priori, problemet handlar om personer som tror de ska finna detta detta syntetiska a priori i fysiska verkligheten.