PITFALLS OF WILBERIAN ECOLOGY - A Critical Review of "Integral Ecology"
Källa: http://www.integralworld.net/markus4.html
Boken är en tillämpning av Wilber integrala teori på området ekologi, dvs: Integral Ecology som är ett försök att integrera över 80 olika skolor inom ekologi och 70 skolor inom miljötänkande.
Artikeln är en kritik av boken, dvs. både ett erkännande och ett ifrågasättande av boken.
Några saker är dock slående: kritiken mot boken faller ofta tillbaka på Wilbers integrala teori, dvs. problemen med Wilbers teori propageras vidare in i applikationen av teorin. Kritikern menar att Integral Ecology egentligen är "WILBERIAN ECOLOGY". Betyder detta att boken är helt värdelös? Nej inte nödväntingtvis.
Först kommer ett citatutrag ur artikelns början, efter detta kommer ett till citat där den huvudsakliga kritikne mot boken tas upp.
Men vad är den främsta kritiken? Jo, att det är vissa antaganden som först måste gZöras för att teorin ska bli meningsfull ö.h.t. Och skribenten menar att dessa inte alls är självklara. Dessa antaganden kan (för att vara kortfattad) ses som en slags "ideologisk grund" som i sig själv inte ifrågasätts, och vi kan kalla dessa för en "position". För att utvecka teorin, behövs dessa antaganden, dvs. "positionen" kunna ifrågasättas.
Men samtigit så vill jag lyfta fram att denna "position" inte är något som är unikt för just integral teori, detta problem verkar även finnas inom ämnen/områden som (för att ge några exempel): "liberalism", "marxism", "feminism". osv.
Hur som helst, här kommer början av artikeln:
ntegral Ecology is an emerging field that applies Ken Wilber's Integral Theory to environmental studies and research. The field has been pioneered, in the last several years, by integral theorist Sean Esbjörn-Hargens and environmental philosopher Michael Zimmerman[1]. Integral Ecology (IE) tries to integrate over 80 schools of ecology and 70 schools of environmental thought. It tries to integrate these approaches by recognizing that environmental phenomena are the result of an observer using a particular method of observation to observe some aspect of nature. This post-metaphysical formula is summarized as Who (the observer) x How (method of observation) x What (that which is observed).
Integral Ecology uses a framework of eight ecological worldviews (e.g.,eco-manager, eco-holist, eco-radical, eco-sage), eight ecological modes of research (e.g., phenomenology, ethno- methodology, empiricism, systems theory), and four terrains (i.e., experience, behaviors, cultures, and systems). The authors start from Wilber's AQAL (all quadrants, all levels) model, with its four fundamental terrains or dimensions: I (subjective, intentionality, individual experience), IT (objective, behaviour), WE (intersubjective, culture/ideas/worldviews) and ITS (interobjective, social and ecological systems).
An integral approach means that all four spheres have to be taken into account and not only the two objective spheres, as modern science and many critics of modernity (from romantics to contemporary radical ecologists) did. But Integral Ecology puts a heavy emphasis on the subjective and intersubjective dimensions, even on some kind of nature mysticism. Integral Ecology is a consequence of the widespread demand that human interior dimensions – personal experience and culture – receive appropriate acknowledgement. For the authors, Integral Ecology is the study of subjective and objective aspecs of organisms in relationship to their intersubjective and interobjective environments at all levels of depth and complexity (IE, 168-9, 173, 478).
Integral Ecology is defined as the mixed methods study of the subjective and objective aspects of organisms in relationship to their intersubjective and interobjective environments. As a result Integral Ecology doesn't require a new definition of ecology as much as it provides an integral interpretation of the standard definition of ecology, where organisms and their environments are recognized as having interiority. Integral Ecology also examines developmental stages in both nature and humanity, including how nature shows up to people operating from differing worldviews. Integral Ecology troes to unite valuable insights from multiple perspectives into a comprehensive theoretical framework—one that can be put to use right now.
The framework is based on Integral Theory, as well as Ken Wilber's AQAL model, and is the result of over a decade of research exploring the myriad perspectives on ecology available to us today and their respective methodologies. The authors argue that to characterize the field adequately and to develop plausible solutions to environmental problems, many different points of view must be represented, including not only the natural and social sciences, but philosophy, religion, cultural norms and values, as well -- perspectives that belong to first-person experience, as in the case of people offering personal testimony about the consequences of environmental hazards. This is not relativism, however, because some perspectives are more coherent and better than others.
The authors argue that Integral Ecology avoids „gross reductionism“ (the reduction of all reality to objective phenomena) and „subtle reductionism“ (the reduction of all interiors to interobjective phenomena) and organizes all perspective into one coherent whole. Subjective and intersubjective dimensions must be interpreted on their own terms and not reduced to (inter)objective phenomena. Dozens of real-life applications and examples of this framework currently in use are examined, including three in-depth case studies: work with marine fisheries in Hawai'i, strategies of eco-activists to protect Canada's Great Bear Rainforest, and a study of community development in El Salvador.
The overall purpose of the book is to present the theory, show how it relates to environmental issues, and then integrate this new way of looking with potential issues in actual study. The first part of the book presents Ken Wilber`s Integral Theory in an accessible way. Explained in the most simplistic terms, this philosophy recognizes that everyone has their own perspective and this perspective colors the way that each person views a particular situation. In this way, some may see an environmental calamity whereas others might not even see an issue. It's not as simply as educating others on such issues. Parts two, three, and four build upon the information presented in the previous section. Part two moves into more explanation of integral ecology, specifically the framework definition and concepts that are important to grasp before moving onto more depth in the next section. Section three then examines how integral ecology would change the way environmental issues would be studied. Finally, the last portion of the book provides a number of interesting and informative case studies which not only illustrate this method of study in real life use but also help to further clarify issues and concepts.
Här har jag klippt ut kritiken:
Methodological pluralism, with its 200+ perspectives, seems a great strength of Iintegral Ecology. But at a closer look this is not so because the authors take into account only specific aspects of other perspectives which can be accomodated into their perspective. Some perspectives – like the theory of bio-social discontinuity, which the authors don't even mention – are not compatible with Integral Ecology in even a very limited sense. Integral Ecology is a very specific perspective with several fundamental aspects:
1. subjectivism, idealism and humanistic voluntarism,
2. progressivism, especially with regard to recent human history,
3. problem-solution (Integral Ecology as the „solution“ of ecological and other problems) and
4. the probability of a sustainable industrial civilization.
One has to accept all of these four (and possibly some others) assumptions if Integral Ecology is to have some sense.
Of course, the authors are well aware that contemporary industrial societies are perhaps not sustainable, but Integral Ecology has sense only if they are sustainable (for worldcentric and planetcentric values are possible only in the global industrial civilization). The authors completely ignore fundamental events (such as peak oil) and fundamental processes (the end of the fossil fuel era) of our time.
Läs hela artikeln här:
http://www.integralworld.net/markus4.html